Florida’s dining scene is often defined by waterfront views and high-end steakhouses, but a recent roundup by food writers across the state suggests that the real magic lies in the “hidden gems”—the rustic shacks, strip mall surprises, and intimate hideaways that locals strive to keep secret.
For residents of Vero Beach and the Treasure Coast, it is no surprise that a local favorite has earned a spot on the prestigious list of Florida’s top 12 hidden gem restaurants worth a road trip. The list, curated by journalists who live and eat in these communities, bypasses the hype to focus on memorable meals and strong personalities.
Treasure Coast Spotlight: 12A Buoy in Fort Pierce
Representing the Treasure Coast is 12A Buoy, a staple located at Fisherman’s Wharf in Fort Pierce. Since opening in 2009, owners Katie James and Owen Hartley have cultivated a reputation for exceptional cuisine served in a setting often described as a “rustic dive.”
Despite its unassuming appearance, the kitchen delivers high-quality seafood that draws diners from across the region. The menu is handwritten on paper, reflecting the fresh, changing nature of their offerings.
Popular appetizers include lobster mac and cheese and hanging extra thick-cut black pepper and maple glaze bacon. Menu favorites include fresh catch fish, raw bar options, fried shrimp, Florida Black Angus burgers and homemade desserts.
For Vero Beach residents, 12A Buoy offers a perfect dining excursion just a short drive south, combining the charm of a working waterfront with culinary excellence that rivals more formal establishments.
Nearby Gems: Melbourne and West Palm Beach
The list also highlighted two other standout locations that are easily accessible for a day trip from Indian River County—one to the north and one to the south.
In Melbourne, Coasters Pub & Biergarten was recognized as a top choice for craft beer enthusiasts and comfort food lovers. Located in a strip mall on East Eau Gallie Boulevard, this gastropub is celebrated for its laid-back atmosphere and massive beer selection.
The venue features an outdoor, dog-friendly biergarten and a menu packed with hearty options. Diners can enjoy truffle fries, burrito bowls, Reuben sandwiches, and specialty burgers. It is the Space Coast’s longest-running craft beer-focused gastropub, making it a reliable stop for a relaxed lunch or dinner.
Heading south to West Palm Beach, The Blue Door offers a completely different vibe. Tucked behind a plain concrete wall on South Dixie Highway, this spot transports guests to a Mediterranean courtyard filled with lush greenery and whitewashed walls.
Executive Chef Nano Crespo serves ingredient-driven dishes inspired by France, Italy, and Greece. The menu features items such as grilled whole branzino, lamb chops, and house-made pasta. The atmosphere is described as “quietly glamorous,” attracting a mix of locals and celebrities looking for a polished yet unpretentious hideaway.
Worth the Drive: Other Florida Favorites
For those willing to travel further, the list includes diverse culinary experiences across the state. From authentic Italian in St. Augustine to creative hoagies in Naples, these spots prove that some of the best food in Florida is found off the beaten path.
Additional highlights from the statewide list include:
Whether sticking to the Treasure Coast to enjoy the seafood at 12A Buoy or embarking on a culinary road trip to Melbourne or West Palm Beach, these hidden gems offer a delicious excuse to explore the unique flavors of the Sunshine State.
